Clive Watches Ghibli: Part 3 (1994-1997)

It's time for part 3 of my adventure to watch all the Studio Ghibli films in order of release and rank them as I go! Head over to parts 1 and 2 here and here respectively if you want to read my thoughts on the earlier Ghibli films. This time we've got the lesser known Pom Poko and Whisper of the Heart as well as the anime giant Princess Mononoke. For the first time each of the three films features a different director with Isao Takahata directing Pom Poko, Yoshifumi Kondo making his directorial debut with Whisper of the Heart before his unfortunate death from overwork shortly after and the legendary Hayao Miyazaki directing his classic Princess Mononoke. Let's get to it.

PomPoko

Pom Poko (1994)

Probably the weirdest Ghibli film I've seen so far. Takahata's Pom Poko tells the story of a tribe of raccoons who are having their habitat mowed down by humans to make way for a new housing development outside of Tokyo. The raccoons have magical testicles (yep, it's a thing) that can help them transform into all sorts of things, which plays a big part in the film's plot. They use these skills, among others, to attempt to thwart the human attempts to build on their land.

Pom Poko delivers its message in a very heavy-handed manner, and coming in at just shy of 2 hours feels a little too long. To me, it doesn't quite justify its running time as the story is very simplistic, never has any major surprises, and doesn't have all that much to say on the topic other than that we need to consider the effects of destroying habitats. A great message no doubt, but not one that needed to be delivered in a fresher way than it is here to hold my interest. I didn't latch onto any of the characters in this one in the same way I have in other Ghibli films, and I have to say it's my least favourite of the bunch so far. Not bad by any means, perfectly watchable, pretty as usual, and there's fun to be had here. But overall I found it a little disappointing.

6/10

Whisper

Whisper of the Heart (1995)

Whisper of the Heart is a pretty straight love story. Shizuku is a bookworm who is constantly taking out books from her school library. She soon notices that all the books she chooses have been checked out by a boy before her and she endeavors to find out who this mysterious guy is. As well as the love story at its core, the film tackles the idea of living as an artist and the sacrifices it entails, a topic that is close to my heart.

I really liked this film. I don't generally like love stories all that much but I found Shizuku completely charming and the relationship depicted never seemed cheesy or overly sappy. I strongly disliked the final scene because it felt so out of place with the rest of the film's tone regarding this but I won't go into more detail as I wouldn't want to spoil anything. Perhaps I just need to see it again? Animation-wise this is one of my favourite looking Ghibli movies, which is quite the achievement. It somehow makes normal neighbourhoods look magical, and the attention to detail is phenomenal. I thought the film had a lot of interesting things to say about honing one's craft as an artist, a theme that was covered in a much more interesting way than a lot of films I've seen. A delightful film slightly hampered by the not-so-great final scene.

8/10

Mononoke

Princess Mononoke (1997)

Princess Mononoke is a hard film to write a blurb for because there's just so much going on but I'll try anyway. Ashitaka is cursed when he defends his village from the attack of a boar god. On his way to find a cure, he finds San, or Princess Mononoke, who is fighting to protect the forest from the local humans,  led by their strong-willed queen Lady Eboshi, who are planning to destroy it.

I'm just going to come right out and say it. This is a masterpiece. My favourite so far. Although longer than Pom Poko (this one comes in at over two hours and ten minutes) none of its running time is wasted and it feels much shorter than that. There is so much going on in this film it's almost ridiculous, and yet it is never confusing or overbearing. The plotting and pacing throughout are masterful. Then there's the animation, which is hands down some of the best I've ever seen, it's thematically much darker than other animations I've seen and this is brought across perfectly in the darker, and yet still bold, colour palette of backgrounds. The film has so many themes: environmentalism, feminism and war being just a few of them and it handles them all in such a way as to never feel preachy, and yet you'll still take a bunch of messages on board. It also has one of the strongest endings you'll see anywhere, not just in animation. A magical piece of art that redefines to me just what an animation film can be.

10/10

Now it's time to throw these three in amongst the other Ghibli films I've seen and see where they rank. This post's films are in bold italics.

1. Princess Mononoke

2. My Neighbour Totoro

3. Grave of the Fireflies

4. Kiki's Delivery Service

5. Laputa: Castle in the Sky

6. Whisper of the Heart

7. Only Yesterday

8. Porco Rosso

9. Pom Poko

Thanks for reading and I'll see you next time for My Neighbours the Yamadas, Spirited Away and The Cat Returns. Stay classy.